Is it time for superhero movies to come out of their Bat Cave?
Like 0 Retweet 0One day deep in the future, after Sasha Obama is sworn in to her second term and the AMPTP and SAG finally work out a new labor agreement, people will look back at this era of superhero movies and think of them the way we think of the Hollywood Western a half century ago. They’ll say, what was going on in the industry — no, what was going on in the world — that made studios crank these out by the dozen. History will show some standouts, but many of them could bleed together.
At least that’s our big fear. Right now there are a lot of high-concept pitches involving men with unconscious powers. No idea is too farfetched, no hook too obscure, to escape the come-hither look of development execs. The last week alone has brought a hand more full of the things than Zod’s hand is full of Kryptoinite.
First there was <a href="http://www.hollywoodreporter.com/hr/content_display/news/e3i78def930c52edb059e4816c907fb2d65
“>wordof the Bryan Singer-produced “Capeshooters,” about slackers who go on the run after coming upon a superhero who turns out to have a nasty streak.
Over the weekend Disney showed the Con masses some footage of a superhero dog named “Bolt,” saving the world from goons one animated panel at a time.
Today comes news that Spider Man studio Sony is trying to extend its Marvel mojo by renewing development vigor on “Venom,” arguably the first spinoff in movie history centered on villainous goo.
And then there’s the “Spider Man” director himself, Sam Raimi, who as Borys Kit reports now has a comedic superhero picture in “The Transplants” that Disney — yes, that Disney — is doing.
(This, incidentally, comes on top of other big-concept fan-driven projects like the one tapped as the first Shaye-Lynne co-prod, Isaac Asimov’s “Foundation,” an adaptation of the sci-fi political epic that involves the prophet and savior Hari Seldon, a kind of intellectual superhero.)
But how similar will all these films be? Let’s hope not very. In this, the summer of “Iron Man” and “The Dark Knight” (Iron Knight?), there’s already not just success but diversity. Despite their comic-book origins, the two films — a cautionary tale about/ednorsement of technology and a civic crime drama — are as different in subject matter as two movies in the same genre can be. And that doesn’t even include the third leg in the summer’s superhero tripod, Hancock, a character piece about redemption that with its p.r. hook and arthouse finish strays further from the parameters of the genre than perhaps any modern superhero film.
But the real determinant in these movies’ legacy/longevity will be how far these movies can keep pushing. A little postmodernism is one thing. But is what’s underneath that cape strong enough to really make movies that feel different? Can all these projects turn the superhero movie from something that endlessly varies the same theme into more of a category, like comedy, than a genre, capable of containing the multitudes of a Disney family film, a biohazard thriller and a slacker comedy.
Or will we just get more Westerns?














July 31st, 2008 at 7:25 AM
Westerns? Time to Bring back the James Bond of the West, The Wild Wild West and do it right without Will Smith.
July 31st, 2008 at 8:09 AM
Yeah, there’s too many comic book movies coming now. I realize it’s part of a cycle, and eventually it’ll die down. But I think the market can’t really handle more than four-to-six high-profile superhero movies a year. More than that and the average fan just can’t keep up. I know I’ve missed some big films this summer because I haven’t had the time to see everything. And that’s money that Hollywood is missing out on.
So I guess when some big budgeted comics-related movies go belly up, the studios will look for a new trend. That’s always the way.
July 31st, 2008 at 9:20 AM
I addressed the same issue at Cinema Blend last week, with particular focus on the Westenrs analogy. God forbid the moment when we get the superhero equivalent of Shane.
August 1st, 2008 at 9:52 AM
The western analogy is fun to use but it doesn’t really apply. Comicbooks are a medium more so than a genre. Westerns are more accurately called a genre and are set in one country (in fact a portion of one country) during one very limited period of time. And the themes of most western stories are universal, adaptable to just about any other genre or period. When you say comics and you mean Superhero stories, they, too, are universal and can be set anywhere, any time, so long as they involve people with unusual abilities. Half the movies made by the Governator could have easily have appeared first in Marvel comics, and most of them were made when comics movies were supposedly “out.” So, no, the “genre” of superhero stories will not fade like the Western. But, no doubt there will be a time when comics-related movies are considered “out” and execs and producers all over town will struggle to distance themselves from any project that smacks of it. And in due course many people will completely misapply the rule while chasing the next big thing (which, may well be supheror movies going by a different name)
August 1st, 2008 at 11:47 PM
If the current trend of keeping true to the essence of a comic continues as seen this summer in both Iron Man and The Dark Knight, “hero” movies can be as timeless as the books themselves. The same comic titles are still selling after several decades, why wouldn’t their live action counterparts do just as well if done right? Comic Con is a huge Hollywood advertising platform but the foundation of Comic Con is us comic geeks of all ages who go to cons all over the country not just in SoCal. This group of people is ready for their heroes to be taken seriously. Think about it, Our parents remember when comics began and our kids are still reading those same stories with a modern twist. If Hollywood wants to pump out films like Shumacher’s Batman & Robin which had nothing to do with the Batman we are finally seeing through the eyes of Chris Nolan, then yes the Hero genre will eventually fade. If the studios follow in Marvel’s footsteps and do the Hero movies right, I think the Hero genre is just beginning.
April 30th, 2009 at 4:05 PM
I always enjoy reading ur articles.
Regards,
Sohrab Khan